On his way into work at an Acme Supermarket in early November, 2019, Plaintiff Andrew Kasbarian slipped and fell on black ice in the parking lot caused by sprinklers that had triggered earlier that chilly morning, suffering a severe shoulder injury requiring surgery. Not able to sue Acme, he sued Albertsons (Acme’s parent company), Parene (the premises’ owner and landlord), and Green Meadows (the landscape contractor) for their negligence in maintaining and failing to warn about the dangerous condition posed by the black ice. The issue in Kasbarian v. Parene Realty Co., LLC, 2026 N.J. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 180 (App. Div. Feb. 3, 2026) was whether any of the defendants were responsible for the black ice formed by the sprinklers that caused Kasbarian’s fall.
Parene was the long-time owner of the premises who had a lease agreement requiring Acme to perform all repairs and maintenance. Green Meadows provided landscaping and irrigation services under a contract with Albertsons that did not require it to winterize and shut down the sprinkler system until Albertsons requested. In fact, that request came three hours after Kasbarian’s fall.
The three defendants challenged Kasbarian’s complaint with summary judgment motions, arguing that, even if the parties agreed to all the facts, Kasbarian could not show they were liable for his injuries. The trial court granted the motions based on the various contracts between the parties and the lack of notice to each defendant, and dismissed the complaint against them, causing Kasbarian to appeal.
On appeal, as to Green Meadows, Kasbarian argued they were a property manager and responsible for maintaining a safe parking lot. Focusing on the contract with Albertsons that only required them to perform sprinkler winterization when Albertsons asked, the Court found Green Meadows had no duty to Kasbarian. They reasoned that Green Meadows lacked the type of relationship with Kasabian that suggested a duty; that, the risk of black ice on the parking lot, an area for which Green Meadows had no control, was one for which Green Meadows could not be held responsible; Green Meadows lacked any opportunity to salt the parking lot and remove the black ice because they were not required to show up until Albertsons asked; and that, if they were to find Green Meadows responsible, that would put the burden on all contractors to winterize all sprinkler systems, no matter their contractual obligation – and that was not reasonable. The Court also found that Green Meadows, who did not come to the Acme parking lot until a few hours after Kasbarian fell, had no actual notice of the black ice or, because the black ice was temporary, they lacked constructive notice.
As for Albertsons, Kasbarian argued that they were vicariously liable because either Green Meadows was their agent or, because they were Acme’s parent company, because of Acme’s negligence. The Court disagreed with these arguments as well, stating that because Green Meadows was not liable, Albertsons could not be vicariously liable. Also, because New Jersey law will not hold a parent company liable for the negligence of a wholly owned subsidiary, they could not be liable for any negligence that Acme may have had.
Finally, the Court found Parene had no liability due to the lease agreement Parene had with Acme. Looking at the interplay of contract and tort law, the Court reaffirmed the rule that, when a lease unambiguously places liability on a tenant, the landlord will not be liable for personal injuries sustained by an employee on that property. Here, through the lease, Parene put the responsibility for all maintenance on its tenant, Acme, and as a result, it had no duty of care for Kasbarian. Further, because Parene was not a party to the Green Meadows/Albertsons contract, they had no responsibility to make sure Green Meadows would winterize the sprinklers in a timely manner.
With the above reasoning focusing on the interplay of the parties’ responsibilities through their various contracts, the Appellate Division affirmed the trial court’s determination that none of the defendants was liable for Kasbarian’s injuries on black ice in the Acme parking lot.
