Notable Wins

Articles › Notable Win: Petitioner’s 100% Jaw Disability Claim Rejected; Respondent Resolves via Section 20 After Full Trial and Judgment

Notable Win: Petitioner’s 100% Jaw Disability Claim Rejected; Respondent Resolves via Section 20 After Full Trial and Judgment

November 12, 2026
By Capehart Scatchard

Client: Burlington County Insurance Pool

Court: Workers’ Compensation

Trial/Brief Attorney: Michelle L. Duffield

**Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances**

Matter Caption: Judith Berkeyheiser v. Bordentown Regional School District

Petitioner, a school aide, was struck in the jaw by a basketball during indoor recess in March 2019. She claimed total disability of the jaw and testified that she had never had problems on the left side before the accident. Her TMJ expert put her disability at 100% of the jaw. Respondent did not dispute compensability but disputed the extent of her disability and its cause. Respondent pointed to petitioner’s three earlier jaw surgeries and to occupational health records from two days after the accident that recorded a history of left-side clicking. Respondent’s orthopedic expert relied on MRI findings showing a normal left joint and degenerative, post-surgical changes on the right side.

After trial, the Judge of Compensation found the 100% rating not credible because it had no objective medical support. The judge also found that petitioner had understated her prior jaw problems. The Judge found 25% permanent partial disability to the left side of the jaw, far below the total disability she sought. The court found that Respondent had carried its burden for a 15% Abdullah credit for her pre-existing condition, which substantially reduces the net award.

Ultimately, Respondent resolved this matter via Section 20 following Trial to eliminate any future exposure to Respondent.

Subscribe to Blog Updates

Choose the blogs and newsletters you would like to receive.

Capehart Blogs

Categories

Share